Don Harlow Reviews
Search for reviews
 
 
What a Girl Wants
What a Girl Wants
» watch the trailer
» check showtimes
» more about the movie

Going in to a sneak preview of this film, I kept thinking of Mel Gibson and the somewhat risqué What Women Want. Coming out, I kept thinking of the puerile The Princess Diaries.

Going in to a sneak preview of this film, I kept thinking of Mel Gibson and the somewhat risqué What Women Want. Coming out, I kept thinking of the puerile (or, more correctly, “puellile”, if such a word exists) The Princess Diaries. On the latter point, our local newspaper reviewer seemed to agree with me, mentioning the same film.

Some eighteen years ago, aristocratic English lad Henry Dashwood (1) (Colin Firth) met Libby Reynolds (Kelly Preston) in Morocco, where they were married in a ceremony that may or may not have been legal. The result of this, when they returned to Merrie Olde England, was a pregnancy and a breakup, the former engineered by the two of them, the latter by Dashwood family advisor Alistair Payne (excellent Welsh character actor Jonathan ap Rhys … excuse me, Pryce). Libby returned to America, where she gave birth to Daphne (Amanda Byrnes), who some seventeen years later got it into her head to go back to England, hunt up her dad, and upset his campaign for the House of Commons, (2) his engagement to Glynnis, the daughter of advisor Payne, and generally turn English society on its head in ways more contrived than likely.

Some nice shots of the Henley Regatta. Otherwise, yawn.


(1) Colin Firth’s staid and boring character seems to have been named for the genuine historical Dashwood family, best known for being associated with the Hellfire Club, a pseudo-satanic group that mainly dabbled in illicit sexual dalliances; Ben Franklin was once a member. I thought it might be a coincidence, until somebody mentioned “Wycombe” in connection with the family estates; the Dashwood family was connected with West Wycombe, a suburb of High Wycombe, home to a U.S. Air Force Station at which I once spent two and a half years forecasting the weather.

(2) As a member of a noble family, Henry had a safe seat in the House of Lords, but he gave it up to run for the Commons. One of David Weber’s characters (actually invented by Eric Flint, I believe) in War of Honor did the same; such an action seemed more likely in science-fiction than it did in a movie supposedly taking place in the real world.

Don Harlow, April 26, 2003 06:29 PM

Feedback
 
Don Harlow bio info. Born longer ago than he cares to admit, Don Harlow has worked as a military weather forecaster, neophyte astronomer, computer programmer and office manager. His primary avocations are reading science-fiction and fantasy and promoting the international language Esperanto. He has successfully raised three daughters and a son, the oldest of whom (Gwen) is responsible for designing this site and giving it to him as a Christmas present. Movies are, for him, a pleasant way of passing an afternoon or evening; his only connection with the movie industry consists in a long-ago four week period during which he worked as an usher at the Lake Theater in Oswego, Oregon. Contact Don at don@harlows.org